The ‘transferable skills’ honed by a group presentation are more readily apparent. Teamwork, leadership, delegation, oral presentation. Yet within my bubble of humanities students, ‘Authentic Assessments’ are often looked upon with disdain, and essays are accepted as the norm for assessment. I rarely hear the question, ‘Why am I writing an essay?’.

However, I frequently hear a similar question, framed in relation to the ‘Real World’ (whatever that means): ‘How will I get a job? All I’ve learnt at university is to write essays.’

There appears to be a disconnect between our understanding of the unquantifiable value of a higher education in the humanities, and our anxiety for this expensive investment to produce tangible, futureproof skills. What working with BILT has made  realise that the crucial skills that essays aim to assess and develop are clear to educators, but not so clear to students.

Students often assume that ‘essays measure essay-writing ability, not employability’, to adapt the famous adage. A degree is a number (1st, 2:1 or 2:2) with which to update LinkedIn bios and CVs; graduates crawl into the job market like newborns, relying on extra-curriculars or internships to speak for their skills.

A rather bleak narrative. And a fictional one.

So, the value of Authentic Assessments notwithstanding, it’s important to reflect upon the tradition of assessment through essays – not to reject it, but to empower students to recognise and articulate the purpose of the essay beyond a unit grade. And in light of calls to defund the humanities in favour of ‘areas of highest national importance’, defending the essay becomes an urgent task for academics.

I would argue that the failure amongst students to recognise the value of essay-writing stems from a failure to recognise the process of ‘writing’ behind the ‘essay’. The grade is the product, stored as data on transcripts; its production is forgotten. When I led essay workshops as a PASS leader in my second year, I was often asked to explain the mark scheme. It called for ‘knowledge and understanding of the subject’, a ‘coherent argument that is logically structured, sustained and supported by evidence’, ‘independent thought and an ability to engage with the material critically’, ‘organisation and style of presentation’. The first-year students wanted to see what this looked like in practice, so we compared exemplars with different marks to see the difference between ‘basic’ and ‘exceptional’ essays.

I understood the skills listed in the mark scheme insofar as they were manifested in an essay, and not the ways in which writing an essay could demonstrate and develop those skills. It was a misinterpretation –- a failure to perform the very close textual analysis that I aimed to teach. After all, ‘essay’ is not only a noun but a verb: to try, to make mistakes and to learn.

It was only when I started applying for internships that I realised my mistake. I read through the aspects of my essays that the markers had rewarded: how could a ‘thorough understanding’ of Tennyson be useful for a role in marketing? But then I started to notice connections across units, so I reconsulted the mark scheme. It was an epiphany. My wide range of sources demonstrated ‘research skills’; my argument structure showed ‘concision and organisation’. I reflected on the very process of writing the essays, not visible to the markers, which had developed my resilience, time-management, curiosity, project-management.

And I soon recognised that this goes beyond summer internships. Prospects identifies that employers are currently reporting a ‘skills shortage’ of traits like ‘creativity and originality; critical thinking and analysis; reasoning and problem solving; resilience and adapt ability; reliability and self-discipline’. Are these not all demonstrated in essays? Even the formulaic ‘PEEL’, ‘PEAL’ and ‘PETAL’ paragraph structures teach students a logical mode of reasoning and critical thinking, developing a hypothesis through evidence and analysis and linking individual insights into a unique argument.

Viewing the essay as a quantifiable list of employable skills is a reductive, the very perspective which the humanities aims to challenge. But these are not merely skills for the workplace. As essayist and author Pat Mora defines it, the essay demands us to ‘articulate our opinions effectively, creatively, and at times, cleverly. Essays require thought, knowledge, organization, and occasionally humor’. These are the characteristics that we value in well-rounded people – and, importantly, they are the human skills that prove that we cannot be replaced by an AI.

So, in changing our attitude towards the types of assessments that we set, we would do well to consider the essay as a medium for development. The task is not to replace one form of assessment with the other, but to recognise the holistic education that their combination can facilitate.

To fully analyse and evaluate the purposes of the essay would itself require an essay, beyond the constraints of a blog post. But please feel free to mark it in the comments and be sure to leave constructive feedback.

As a plenary, I give a few suggestions from my experience with both teachers and learners:

  • Encourage students to evaluate their process of writing the essay. What did it teach them? What will they do differently, not only in the next essay but in future projects?
  • Provide opportunities for reflection on marking feedback. How does it connect to feedback received in other units? What skills have they developed through their university experience?
  • Think holistically. What skills might they need to develop further, and how could they use experiences outside of academia to do so? Why should these skills be important to them?

Discover more from Bristol Institute for Learning and Teaching

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending